I’ve always loved a good red nail polish, but nine times out of 10 I’d plump for a nude given the choice. Common’ you know how I feel about Nails Inc Porchester Square? If you’re new round these parts it’s basically my desert island nail colour; because if I was stranded painting my nails would be top of my priorities, of course. But for the past three months or so, pretty much exclusively, blackened plums have ruled the roost. Chic and understated, in a ‘I rolled out of bed and my nails were just painted like this’ kind of way and a flatterer of short cut nails. Here I dedicate a few words to my favourite five…

In my head this post would be a little overview of each colour, with a few comparisons and shade run-downs thrown in but when I lacquered up each nail it became increasingly obvious that we had five dupes on our hands here. There are a few minute differences though which I will endeavour to beef this post out with. From left to right we have Butter LONDON Nail Lacquer in La Moss, By Terry Nail Lacque in Terrybly Terry, Revlon Nail Enamel in Vixen, CHANEL Le Vernis in Rouge Noir and Essie Nail Polish in Luxedo. Of the five the CHANEL paints on the smoothest with no streaking, the By Terry is the most purple and has the best brush and the Essie is the blackest of the all. The By Terry also has the shiniest finish sans top coat and out of the bunch Vixen and Rouge Noir look almost identical which is fabulous news given the rather hefty CHANEL price point.

The lesson learnt from this post? A black cherry nail is a black cherry nail – they all look the same. And the fact that I have another five or so tucked away in my stash that could have easily made it into this post, means that it might be about time to have a clear out.

shop the post

  • Talisa Lauren Tossell
  • Anna Blush

    Love this shade for Christmas time, so chic and festive

    http://anna-blush.blogspot.com

  • Natasha Kembrey

    I love it for this time of year x

    http://www.tillylions.blogspot.com

  • The Finch’s Beak

    The best colour for autumn/winter- I love Nails Inc Victoria

    Josie http://thefinchsbeak.wordpress.com/

  • http://lovethatlavenderbrunette.blogspot.com/ Monica

    I wonder how Luxedo compares to Wicked? I’ve been trying to track down Wicked for a few weeks now, but with no luck =(.

    http://lovethatlavenderbrunette.blogspot.com/

    • http://meteobeauty.blogspot.com/ Selma Gabela

      I think that Wicked has more brown pigment in and is a tad lighter than Luxedo. I just purchased Luxedo and am in love with it :)

  • Lisi

    How do these compare to the Clinique Black Honey one?

  • Emily Golding

    It’s amazing that I can tell your fingers anywhere now after reading all these amazing posts!

    Emily
    http://www.beautybyemily.co.uk

  • http://emmabebeauty.blogspot.ie/ Emma Be Beauty

    Love these type of colours.

  • Sarah Beth

    These look so similar! Rouge Noir and Luxedo are my favourites xxx

    StudentBeauty

  • Millie Robinson

    Love these shades for winter! I must try the Revlon one it looks gorgeous for the price :) x

    http://abeautyromancee.blogspot.co.uk
    http://abeautyromancee.blogspot.co.uk

  • Maddy Cane

    Love the look of the Butter london one, such a pretty colour! x

    Maddy from UNSTITCHEDD

    ♥

  • Ella

    I love sole mate, it’s so striking! If you put a layer of toggle to the top (from their new mini winter set thing) over the top, it gives your manicure a lil Christmassy boost too!

  • http://emmihearts.blogspot.co.uk/ Emily Allen

    I love nail polish shades like this especially at this time of year! i love the butter london shade best cause its almost black when you look at it xx

    EmmiHearts

  • Emily Knott
  • roshkud

    Love black cherry colours! I need to buy the essie one

  • Arpita Bajaj

    I adore the fact that you have 5 different colours on, yet no one would be able to tell! Now I need to go on a hunt for Vixen!

  • http://raeey.tumblr.com/ Rachel

    I’m obsessed with this color all year round. Revlon’s Vixen has been repainted countless times, love that you included a range of brands and prices for this amazing winter color.

  • Glamoury armory

    I love this post! thanks you. I need the essie one!

  • http://ameliarosel.blogspot.co.uk/ AmeliaRoseL

    I have a shade like this from Avon and adore it. I wear it all the time in the autumn and winter.

    AmeliaRose | Beauty Blogger

  • http://www.cindyslittleblackbook.com/ Cindy

    These nail polish is perfect for the Holidays! I bought from similar from Formula X by Sephora

  • Amber Hunter

    I don’t think you can really go wrong with a dark red for the holidays. I just got a gel manicure today with a gorgeous wine color! Not quite a black cherry but a beautiful deep red. I want to say it’s called malaga wine by OPI? Something like that haha.

    Amber

    Lovely Notions

  • http://ten-sixteen.blogspot.com/ Nicole K

    A black cherry nail is definitely something I’ve been loving lately… even though it’s summer here.

    xx Nicole
    http://npk-blog.blogspot.com

  • http://www.vibrantbeautyblog.com/ Jennifer Monforton

    Love this shade of nails for Winter! The Butter London and By Terry polishes look especially lovely :)

  • http://blog-de-la-licorne.blogspot.sk/ Gabrielle RoseBonniee
  • http://xsimplynitax.blogspot.com/ Nita

    After reading this, I really need a black cherry nail polish in my collection :)

    -Nita
    xsimplynitax.blogspot.com

  • need a gap

    Burgundy is pretty much the only color I use on the nails in the winter :) Great shades!! xx

    http://needagap.blogspot.com/