The ‘New’ Lip Pencils

Lip pencils aren’t what they used to be – oh no. Although the classic matte-formula ‘draw around your lip line’ thingies are still around, there’s a new generation of lipstick/lipbalm/lipstain hybrids all packaged up into handy pencil form that seem to be the flavour of the month right now. So here’s a run-down of the three that I’ve got locked up in my stash…

First up, the original – Clinique Chubby Stick. I picked up one of these for the first time last week and plumped for the shade Curvy Candy. Out of the three this is probably the most ‘well-rounded’ – pigmented colour, a glossy sheen and it’s pretty moisturising too. The only thing that dissapointed me was the shade range; all the shades seemed quite dark, no peachy pink to be seen! Say what? Clinique are missing out on a trick there, if they bought out a shade like that I’d stock up by the bucket load! Next up is one of the newer ones on the scene, the Soap & Glory Sexy Mother Pucker Gloss Stick in Nudist*. I’ve cracked this out in quite a few videos recently and it’s the lip product that I was whispering about here, it’s a great ‘your lips but a little nuder and glossier’ shade. Unfortunately there are only three shades to pick from here and they’re not particularly long-lasting but a good choice for a nice touch of moisturising gloss on the go. Finally the one that looks like it might topple the humble Chubby Stick off it’s hero lip product throne for many, Revlon’s Just Bitten Kissable Balm Stain in Charm. This has cropped up on my blog quite a few times before. I adore the shade, it’s super smooth and moisturising on the lips and leaves a pinky orange stain on the lips, hours after the balm has worn away. The only problem here is that Revlon didn’t release this shade in the UK – boooo. But formula-wise, this gets a thumbs up from me.

The good thing with all three of these is that none of them require sharpening – just a little twist at the end is all that’s needed to reveal more product. But for me, not one of them hits the nail exactly on the head just yet – I’ll be throwing my arms in the air in excitable shapes when a long-lasting nude peachy pink balm stain lip pencil thingie-ma-jig hits the market, in the UK. So who wants to give that a go?

*PR Sample

  • magpiebox.blogspot.co.uk

    I have a clinique chubby stick in ‘mega melon’ and a revlon lipstain in ‘crush’, neither of them are exactly what I am looking for, will have to give soap and glory a try! megan x

  • Margaret

    I have to get the revlon balm stain and I want to give the soap and glory one a go as well, seems so lovely! love the post! x

    http://www.ajumpinmargaretslife.blogspot.com

  • http://drummingheartbeat.blogspot.com/ Jenny (Cherry Gumdrops)

    I’ve got two chubby sticks and one revlon lipstain and I like both products for their different qualities – I love the Clinique for a sheer colour but the Revlon is great for a stronger colour x

  • MissLauren x
  • Jules

    Hi Anna! When are the Soap and Glory ones out? Can’t see them on the S&G website:( Must give that one a go but I’d also love a nude peachy pink shade! Love your blog!

  • http://www.shelovesthefinerthings.blogspot.in/ Yewizzy

    The Clinique one looks like it was made for MAC’s Girl About Town..Love it..x

    http://www.shelovesthefinerthings.com/

  • Georgina Burnell

    I want to get the chubby sticks so bad, but at 16 quid it would blow the bank if I got a few ha
    Missbrunettex.blogspot.com

  • Emma Computergirl

    LOVE my chubby sticks :) Not tried the others but the clinique ones are my staple go to x

  • Emily

    Love these, better than lipstick in my opinion!

    thebeautymist.blogspot.com

  • http://twitter.com/CityGirlFashBox Sarah Sandiford

    I completely agree about the totally naff Clinique shades, but i think that completely and utterly comes up the brand entirely, stuck in the 80′s with an almost clinical feel! x

  • Michelle Torres

    Weird… I would classify Clinique’s Mega Melon as a perfect peach color as well as the Mimosa color is a pink that leans to peach on many people. Hope that helps!

  • http://twitter.com/alicebeaa alice bea ☯

    I definatly want to get the revlon one, i hope they hurry up and release it here!
    whatalicedidtoday.blogspot.co.uk

  • Alex

    The Revlon balm stains ar really gorgeous, definitely a winner :) I have 3, and am building my collection, but I agree – we need more shades in the UK!

  • Silvia Quirós

    I haven´t try any of them but they look great! I like the concept of chubby pencil!! thanks for sharing!

  • Hollie Galvin

    I have the lip balm stain in cherish and find it a bit too shimmery for my liking!
    I really want to try the original chubby sticks though..simply because of the name! x

  • http://twitter.com/sophiefox Sophie ✌

    you can get the revlon kissable stain in charm on ebay! its about 7 pounds with free p&p! xxxx

  • Valerie

    I love these, but after smelling the clinique ones in the store, I couldn’t bring myself to buy them (I’ve actually felt that way about most clinique lip products–it does sit just under my nose, after all!). Does the scent fade over time or do you just grin and bear it?

    • Angel

      What are you talking about? They’re 100% fragrance free as are all of there products!

  • http://twitter.com/jessicadinelia Jessica

    your post made these lip products sound magical. like i was reading a fairytale makeup blog. youre wonderful

  • Jos

    I so want to try one of the Clinique Chubby Stick! But I can’t decide
    which shade(s) to choose, and I’m kinda hoping they will launch new
    colours – a girl can dream right?

    They seem so easy to through on!

    Xxx

    http://gobigorgohomehoney.blogspot.fr/

  • The pretty lil things

    Charm is available on ebay, waiting for mine!

  • http://www.facebook.com/smecksie Melanie Carek

    I think Tarte may have been one of the first to come out with a new line of jumbo lip pencils with balm/stain qualities. Theirs are wonderful!! I have it in two shades and they are just my absolute favorite lip products. I don’t know if Tarte is available in the UK, but if you find them, they are definitely worthy of excitable arm flailing displays. ;) http://tartecosmetics.com/tarte-item-lipsurgence-natural-lip-tint

  • Marie

    I just bought a few of the New-CID ‘iKiss’ lip pencils from my local TK Maxx and I love them! (apart from their insistence on naming all their products i-whatever in a cheesy Millennium kind of way). They are more matte than the Revlon and Clinique products you mention but the staying power is amazing.

  • Elle h

    i feel like i’m the only person who can not make this work…. much prefer my laura mercier lip glace! x

  • Lipstick Fridays

    I have charm and just love it x can’t wait to get my hands on the soap and glory one too xx

  • http://www.charlies-choice.blogspot.com/ CharliesChoice

    I don’t like the Clinique ones, they don’t last more than an hour on my lips. Haven’t tried the others though.

  • Bárbara Ferreira

    I agree with the Clinique shades.
    I much prefer the Revlon one over the Clinique chubby stick, I haven’t tried the by soap and glory yet.
    xx-B
    http://thegreyclover.blogspot.co.uk/

  • http://twitter.com/SBeauty101 Sandra

    I love the Clinique chubby sticks. My favorite is the Whoopin’ Watermelon. It’s actually quite ”neutral” if you ask me. I expected it to be bright pink, but in reality, it’s ‘your lips but better’ kind of color. I would definitely recommend it! :)

    Sandra from The Puzzle of Sandra’s Life

  • thebeautyheroes

    need to get the Revlon stick, looks so good for its price x
    thebautyheroes.blogspot.co.uk

  • viikkiii.blogspot.com

    I might just have to purchase one of these and add them to my ever expanding make up collection XD

  • Charlotte

    I picked up a chubby stick in Mighty Mimosa the other and it’s quite peachy/pinky! Also agree that Whoppin’ watermelon is a nice shade.

    http://www.anenglishrosebeautyblog.blogspot.com

  • Angel

    Being a darker skinned woman, I’m pretty pleased with the Clinique shade range of chubby sticks. I have ‘fabulous fig’ and it’s great, all the shades are barely there and sheer so I’m surprised you didn’t take to any.

    Shades like the Revlon Charm would look horrid on me and make me look sick!

    So keep doing what your doing Clinique!! =)

  • FloribundaR

    I do love the Revlon ones, the clinique ones look nice but seem kind of overpriced now that the high street are offering such similar products… xo

  • Rachael madeupoflittlethings

    I’ve looked at several of these but never yet found a shade that is ‘me’. The search continues … ! rachael @ madeupoflittlethings xx

  • http://twitter.com/miss_lara мιѕѕ.ℓαяα

    I really want the Sexy Mother Pucker Gloss Stick <3

  • http://www.maamerose.com/ Roselyn Omane – Frempong

    I recently purchased the MUA version of these – I can’t remember the colour I got as I don’t have it with me right now, but I was pleasantly surprised by the formula. I found it more creamy than greasy!

    Rose

    xx

    maamerose.com